The ecology of the GULGUTHRA (Shit Eaters) (Neo-shit Eaters)
by Ed Greenwood


 
Dragon - Monsters - Dragon #96
- - Notes - -

    The Gulguthra, or "Dung Eaters" (the
otyugh and neo-otyugh), are strange and
deadly creatures indeed. I asked Elminster
about them some time ago, and it happened
that upon his next visit the house was --
unexpected by us both -- full of children; a
captive audience to any sage worth his
tongue. Elminster did not disappoint.

    "Gather round," he said with a twinkle in
his eye, "and I'll tell you of Erammon and
the Kitchen Midden." He waited until the
small whirlwind of visiting nieces and nephews
had settled at his feet, and his pipe had
drawn into life, green smoke rings rising
from it. I had introduced him as "Uncle
El," and he was enjoying the role gleefully
-- although he had muttered an aside to me
that it had better only last this one night.
I'll set down the tale as he told it -- although,
of course, without the voices'.
(Elminster is a master vocal mimic when he
wants to be.)
 

Erammon was a minor lordling of the
eastern Dales -- of Harrowdale on the
Inner Sea. even then a sleepy farmer's land.
His father, the Lord Oraun, was wise and
just, strong in battle, and well respected in
the Dales. Erammon was a young prince
like any other, reckless and fun-loving and
full of himself. He longed for battles and
ravening monsters and fell wizards so that
he could swing his shining sword and win
the day and walk into the taverns in Harrowdale
to a hero's welcome (and not the
usual hushed, wary silence). One day he
asked his swordmaster why Harrowdale was
so tranquil (that was not the word he used)
and why his father was so respected as a
fighter, since Oraun never seemed to fight.

    The swordmaster, old Thaeron, replied:
"Harrowdale's at peace because it's strong,
boy, and it's strong because of your father. I
fought with him, in the wars with Thar and
with the outcasts of Sembia; he's a man to
be feared over blades."

    "But why then does he not fight? Erammon
persisted. "Why does he not raid into
the elven-woods, or strike down the upstart
in Scardale?"

    Thaeron fixed a cold eye on the prince
and said, "The wise man fights only when
he has to. The fewer enemies made,. the
fewer to come at you all at once."

    "But father has enemies," said Erammon.
"Scardale, and Featherdale --
e v e r y o n e ? s   a n   e n e m y   o f   A r c h e n d a l e .   .   .   . ?

    ? A y e ,   b u t   t h e y   a r e   e n e m i e s   w h o   f e a r   h i m
m o r e   t h a n   t h e y   h a t e   h i m .   R e m e m b e r   t h a t ,
b o y   ?   w h e n   t h e   h a t e   o v e r c o m e s   t h e   f e a r ,
y o u ? l l   s e e   t h e i r   s w o r d s .   B e s i d e s ,   y o u r   f a t h e r
p r o t e c t s   t h e   d a l e s   t o   t h e   s o u t h   f r o m   t h e   f e l l
e l v e s ,   a n d   t h e   b r i g a n d s   w h o   l i v e   i n   t h e
w o o d s   a l o n g   t h e   r i v e r   L i s . ?

    ? B u t   I ? v e   n e v e r   e v e n   s e e n   a n   e l f ,   o r   a
b r i g a n d ! ?   E r a m m o n   p r o t e s t e d .

    ? H e   d o e s   a   g o o d   j o b ,   t h e n , ?   r e p l i e d
T h a e r o n ,   w r i n k l i n g   h i s   m o u s t a c h e   i n t o
w h a t   m i g h t   h a v e   b e e n   a   g r i n .

    ? B u t   h o w   d o   t h e   o t h e r   l o r d s   t h i n k   t h e s e
b r i g a n d s ,   a n d   t h e   e l v e s ,   s o   d a n g e r o u s   ?
a n d   H a r r o w d a l e ? s   f o r c e   o f   a r m s   s o   s t r o n g ? ?
t h e   p r i n c e   d e m a n d e d .

    T h a e r o n   w a s   s i l e n t   f o r   a   m o m e n t ,   a n d
t h e n   s a i d ,   ? T h o s e   w h o   c o m e   t h r e a t e n i n g
y o u r   f a t h e r ,   o r ,   c o m e   u n i n v i t e d ,   h e   d o e s   n o t
p r o t e c t   ?   a n d   t h e y   v a n i s h ;   t h i s   t h e   o t h e r
lords know.?

? B u t   I ? v e   n e v e r   e v e n   s e e n   a n   e l f ,   o r   a
b r i g a n d ! ?   E r a m m o n   p r o t e s t e d .
 

? H e   d o e s   a   g o o d   j o b ,   t h e n , ?   r e p l i e d
T h a e r o n ,   w r i n k l i n g   h i s   m o u s t a c h e   i n t o
w h a t   m i g h t   h a v e   b e e n   a   g r i n .

? B u t   h o w   d o   t h e   o t h e r   l o r d s   t h i n k   t h e s e
b r i g a n d s ,   a n d   t h e   e l v e s ,   s o   d a n g e r o u s   ?
a n d   H a r r o w d a l e ? s   f o r c e   o f   a r m s   s o   s t r o n g ? ?
t h e   p r i n c e   d e m a n d e d .

T h a e r o n   w a s   s i l e n t   f o r   a   m o m e n t ,   a n d
t h e n   s a i d ,   ? T h o s e   w h o   c o m e   t h r e a t e n i n g
y o u r   f a t h e r ,   o r ,   c o m e   u n i n v i t e d ,   h e   d o e s   n o t
p r o t e c t   ?   a n d   t h e y   v a n i s h ;   t h i s   t h e   o t h e r
lords know.?

? B u t   I ? v e   n e v e r   s e e n   a n y   f i g h t i n g ,   n o r
a n y   s t r a n g e r s   w i t h   s w o r d s . ?

? O n l y   b r i g a n d s   t h r e a t e n   w i t h   s w o r d s ,
b o y , ?   T h a e r o n   a n s w e r e d .   ? L e a r n   t h a t ,   i f
y o u   l e a r n   n o t h i n g   e l s e   f r o m   m e . ?   T h e
s w o r d m a s t e r   p a u s e d ,   j e r k e d   h i s   h e a d   i n   t h e
d i r e c t i o n   o f   t h e   f e a s t i n g   h a l l ,   a n d   s a i d ,
? C o m e . ?

? T o   t h e   h a l l ? ?   E r a m m o n   a s k e d ,   f o l l o w i n g
h a s t i l y .

"T h i s   i s   w h e r e   a l l   g u e s t s   c o m e ,   i s   i t   n o t ? ?
T h a e r o n   r e p l i e d ,   w a v i n g   a n   a r m   a t   t h e
g r e a t   h a l l ,   w h e r e   s e r v a n t s   w e r e   s c r u b b i n g
a n d   d u s t i n g   a n d   f i l l i n g   l a m p s   w i t h   o i l   f o r
t h e   e v e n i n g   a h e a d .   ? A y e , ?   E r a m m o n   s a i d ,
n o t   u n d e r s t a n d i n g   w h y   t h e   s w o r d m a s t e r
had brought him here.

"And then they go to your father's chambers
for wine and sweets, do they not?"
Thaeron continued.

? A y e , ?   s a i d   t h e   p r i n c e   a g a i n   ?   a n d   t h e n
h i s   m i n d   l e a p e d   a h e a d .   ? Y o u   m e a n   .   .   .
p o i s o n ? ?   A t   t h a t ,   T h a e r o n   t u r n e d   o n   h i m   a
l o o k   o f   s u c h   c o l d   d i s g u s t   t h a t   t h e   p r i n c e
r e c o i l e d   a s   t h o u g h   m e n a c e d   b y   a   d a g g e r thrust .

? N o !   Y o u   t h i n k   t h e   o t h e r   l o r d s   h a v e   n o
s p i e s   i n   o u r   k i t c h e n s ?   N o r   y o u r   f a t h e r   i n
t h e i r s ?   N o   o n e   d a r e s   t o   u s e   p o i s o n   i n   t h e
D a l e s ,   l e s t   a l l   t h e   o t h e r   l o r d s   r e t a l i a t e . ?

? W h a t ,   t h e n ? ?
 

? S o m e   v i s i t o r s   d i s a p p e a r ,   d o   t h e y   n o t ? ?
t h e   s w o r d m a s t e r   a s k e d ,   r e t u r n i n g   t o   h i s
e a r l i e r   l i n e   o f   d i s c o u r s e .   E r a m m o n   n o d d e d .
? S o ,   e v e n   y o u   h a v e   n o t i c e d   t h a t , ?   t h e   o l d
w a r r i o r   s a i d   s a r c a s t i c a l l y .

? A n d   h o w   n o t ? ?   s a i d   E r a m m o n   i n   a n
i r r i t a t e d   t o n e .   ? W o r d   s p r e a d s ,   a m o n g   t r a v e l e r s   a s   w e l l   a s   a m o n g   t h o s e   w h o   l i v e   i n
H a r r o w d a l e . ?

? A y e ,   t a l k   t r a v e l s , ?   T h a e r o n   a g r e e d .
? T h o s e   w h o   d i s a p p e a r   a r e   b r i g a n d s ,   o r   s o
y o u r   f a t h e r   t e l l s   t h e   g o s s i p s . ?

? B u t   ?   n o   b o n e s ?   N o   c o r p s e s   o n   t h e
b a t t l e m e n t s ? ?   E r a m m o n   a s k e d ,   s t i l l   b e w i l d e r e d .   T h e   p a i r   k e p t   w a l k i n g   t h r o u g h   t h e
h a l l ,   a n d   T h a e r o n   m a d e   a   g e s t u r e   t o w a r d
t h e   f a r   e n d .

? T h e   k i t c h e n s ?   Y o u   m e a n   w e  eat  . . . ??
The prince gasped and began to go pale.

Thaeron shook his head. ?One so dense
will not hold Harrowdale for long, helmhead!? he barked. ?What is a corpse but
garbage? And where do the kitchen-maids
throw the garbage??

?In the midden,? Erammon said, following the swordmaster up to a stout, barred
wooden door.

?Have you not wondered why the balcony of your father?s audience chamber
overlooks the stink of his kitchen midden??
Thaeron asked, unlocking the last chain and
hurling its bar aside.

?Oh.? Erammon thought for a moment.
?Yes . . . yes, so it does. But why??

Thaeron swung open the door and
pointed out into the fetid pit beyond, ringed
by a stout palisade of weathered timbers.
?Look out to the base of the wall there . . .
look hard, and look for an enemy.? Erammon peered into the midden as he had been
told, and suddenly realized that he had
locked gaze with ?

?An eye!? he cried. ?An eye ? coming
up from the ground like a worm!?

Thaeron was already pulling the door
closed, but an instant before it slammed
shut, Erammon saw the festering garbage
ripple, undulating right before his wide eyes
as though the refuse itself was alive.

?But ? but ? what is it, out there??
Erammon fairly screamed.

Thaeron fastened chains and set bars in
place for a long time before he turned to
face the prince. When he did, his face was
blank, his eyes cold and level. ?Only your
father can tell you that, Erammon,? he said.
?And if I were you, I?d make sure he was in
a good mood when I asked him.?
 

The children were petrified, or thrilled,
or asleep when Elminster finished the tale.
They were tucked into their beds, and
?Uncle El? and I took up mugs of cocoa
and sat for a time in silence, enjoying the
peace of the evening by the fireside. Then I
broke the quiet, opening a discussion I
could wait no longer to have.

?That was an otyugh in the midden?? I
asked, for the benefit of my hidden tape
recorder.

?Was,? Elminster replied. ?It turns out
that Lashan, at least, knew of it ? when he
overran Harrowdale, his archers emptied
flasks of oil and then quiversfull of flaming
arrows from that balcony until the whole
midden was aflame.?

?What about Erammon??

?He lives, some say, hiding in exile, but
has not come to reclaim his seat since
Lashan?s fall. Certainly his body has not
been found. Thaeron died fighting Lashan?s
armies . . . and of course Oraun died of
heart-stop some winters ago.? The sage
stared into the fire and shrugged. ?Interesting times, indeed. But I have more than a
tale to answer your query. I have brought
with me a certain document, and know
more besides. Bend thine ears, then ? and
be sure that recording instrument you hide
so well is working properly.?

I flushed a bit, shifted in my seat to hide
my embarrassment, and leaned forward
attentively as Elminster began to read. . . .
 

From a report by Phiraz of the Naturalists to the Commissioner of Public Sewers
in the city of Scornubel:
 

. . . The greatest of the nuisance crea-
tures that will plague your system is the
?dungheap? or otyugh, a scavenger of the
strangest appearance and habits. The otyugh and its larger cousin, the neo-otyugh,
share the form of a pile of festering dung
with a toothed maw set into it. An otyugh?s
body is lumpy, mottled purple, green, and
(primarily) brown, and the creature stumps
about on three fat legs of similar appearance. From this delightful bulk ? which the
creature is wont to bury in piles of rubbish
and dung ? protrude two long1 ridged
tentacles with large, heart-shaped gripping
ends, and a flesh-colored and segmented
wormlike stalk containing two yellow-purple
eyes. A buried otyugh watches its surroundings constantly by means of this stalk, so
look for it when you suspect that one of
these creatures is near.

An otyugh is never surprised by the
approach of a creature; take care that you
or your men are not in turn surprised by
one lying in wait. Otyughs often happily
attack and kill parties of three people or
less; they will eat fresh meat as readily as
they consume carrion, dung, or offal. Beware this predator!

Otyughs are terrifically strong, able to
snatch warriors off their feet, armor and all,
and fling them aside as children throw dolls.
They are under no circumstances to be
fought a1one.2

The otyugh is most often solitary, but
may exist in symbiosis with another (often
more dangerous or energetic) creature, such
as a doppleganger, ettin, will-o-the-wisp, or
even a beholder. For such creatures they
serve to guard treasure, which they always
conceal at the very bottom of their offal
pile, hidden from view beneath the otyugh
itself. Encountering an otyugh is bad
enough ? but if you do see one, be sure to
look around for another even more fearsome foe!

Thankfully, otyughs mate only seldom
(perhaps once in every seven years or so),
traveling by night and subterranean routes
to bonepits deep under the earth, where the
remains of many ancient creatures lie in
vast layers. There they mate in mass gatherings with others of their kind who have
made the same journey. 3

Notes

1. Elminster provided precise details of a
gulguthra?s reach (tentacles can grow up to
14 feet in length, fully extended) and senses.
An otyugh can communicate telepathically
with creatures up to 4? away; the neootyugh?s telepathic range is 6?, and the
higher intelligence of the latter creature
enables it to communicate on a more sophisticated level with creatures it encounters. Only rarely, however, will a gulguthra
initiate such communication, for it has little
to "say" to any other creatures. The eyes of
a gulguthra have infravision and ultravision,
both out to a range of 9". Both eyes
are positioned on the same side of their
stalk, but this does not contribute to any
lack of alertness because the eyestalk continually
swivels, periscope-style, and any
creature that comes within range of its
visual powers is instantly detected. (The
creature does sleep, but only when it is not
threatened, and even in this semi-dormant
state, its eyestalk and eyes function as
though it were awake, for the purpose of
detecting approaching creatures.) The eyes
function very well in gloom or darkness, but
narrow to mere blurred slits in bright sunlight --
for which reason the creature lives below ground.
The presence of a torch or
the casting of a light spell can sometimes
so disconcert these creatures that they do no
attack. Gulguthra cannot smell with any
acuity, probably due to the dung and decay
that customarily surrounds them, and so they cannot
track prey, nor reaily discern
the true natures of disguised creatures.

2. Phiraz, never having fought a
gulguthra and having viewed only one such
encounter through the eyes of a sedentary
scholar and not a fighting-man, is both
vague and brief as to their fighting style and
abilities. Elminster has other sources, and
their information boils down to this: When
it is attacking, an otyugh's tentacles erupt
from the concealing pile of offal and slap
victims with force equivalent to 18 (no
percentile) strength for purposes of matching
the creature's grip or the force of its
thrust against the strength of an opponent.
A tentacle does 1-8 points of damage on a
slap that hits its target, and can also curl
about an opponent within range, constricting
for 2-4 points of damage per round until
the hold is broken. The otyugh can lift a
grasped opponent and hurl the victim into a
pit or against a wall; the more intelligent
neo-otyugh also likes to use a grasped creature
as a shield, flailing the victim about to
fend off attacks from other adversaries.

    Either sort of creature can sense when a
grasped opponent is weakened or disabled,
and will try to push such prey into reach of
its suckerlike, toothed mouth. Due to the
creature's favored habitat (proximity to
dung and carrion) and its digestive system
(wastes are spat back out of its mouth),
anyone bitten will suffer both 2-5 points of
damage and a 90% likelihood of contracting
typhus (treat as a parasitic infestation; see
pages 13-14 of the DMG). There are no
known cases of gulguthra suffering from
any such diseases carried in waste and filth
themselves, and they are thought to be
immune or at least highly resistant to these.

3. Phiraz again is vague; his research had
gone so far as to confirm at least the partial
truth (periodic journeys far underground) of
a legend concerning gulguthra mating --
but, having a mistrust of legends, he merely
reported it briefly and without comment.
Elminster checked with the sorcerer known
as Jovriam of the Mines, and certain
svirfneli, and was able to glean the following
facts and observations.

Every gulguthra is bisexual. Each produces,
oncce every seven winters, a jellylike
"eggmass" and travels underground (in a
slow, patient journey) by instinct and memory
until it reaches others of its of its kind. Then
it regurgitates the eggmass from a secondary
stomach and wanders off, that part of its
task done. In some manner not yet understood,
another gulguthra can fertilize any
eggmass (except its own) by taking it briefly
into its mouth, or perhaps some internal
organ, and expelling it again.

    An eggmass that is fertilized, if left undisturbed,
will develop in one week's time into
a miniature version of the parent that provided
the eggmass. (An otyugh eggmass will
only produce another otyugh, and likewise
for the neo-otygh, even though either
species can fertilize any eggmass) This
"newborn" creature is driven by by an instinctual
urge to find warmth and food, and will
wander off to seek its own "fortune," returning
to its birthplace years later to breed
in its turn.

    Gulguthra young are smaller (3-5 HD)
and weaker (damage of 1-6/1-6/1-4. tentacle
strength of 16) than mature specimes, bu
are otherwise identical to their parents, and
grow to maturity within 4 months.